What medical devices do you have in your office? Do you often use a computer or a handheld device? What about ultrasound
or bone densitometry? These days, it's hard not to use some kind of medical technology in your practice. Indeed, the pervasive
use and promise of medical devices has prompted the Bush administration to call for the implementation of at least one form
of these tools by 2014—specifically, information technology such as electronic medical records (EMRs).1
As the role of technology in medical practice continues to grow, Contemporary OB/GYN wanted to determine which procedures, diagnostic testing, and medical equipment are currently used by ob/gyns and what role
these tools will play in the future. To that end, Advanstar Communications Research Services, an entity of this magazine's
parent company, Advanstar Medical Economics, sent questionnaires to 2,000 physicians nationwide. (Completed surveys were returned
by 263 ob/gyns—for a response rate of 13%.)
The responding ob/gyns come from all over the United States. On average, they have 18 years of experience under their belts
and see 84 patients per week. Nearly two thirds are male. About half belong to a group practice, three out of 10 are in solo
practice, and three out of 20 work in partnership with one other physician.
So what medical technology are you and other ob/gyns adopting? Our survey provides some insights.
Most ob/gyns screen for cervical cancer, osteoporosis
 TABLE 1 Medical procedures: How do you rate against your colleagues?
|
The vast majority of ob/gyns surveyed (92%) perform Pap testing (fluid-based cytology) to screen for abnormal cells in the
cervix. Respondents said they perform this procedure an average of 36 times per week (Table 1). In contrast, less than a quarter
reported they still use automated Pap testing.
An equally high percentage—90%—performs colposcopy. This suggests that ob/gyns frequently turn to this tool after receiving
abnormal results from a Pap test. One female physician from the Midwest, who sees 60 patients in a typical week, also acknowledges
that the ability to perform this procedure in the office helps her to reduce the number of referrals she makes to specialists.
Of all ob/gyns surveyed, 88% said they also utilize human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA testing—about 14 times in a typical week.
According to an ob/gyn in the Midwest who sees about 60 patients per week, this test has had the most impact on her solo practice
because of its "ability to diagnose positive (results) and eliminate false-negative results of Pap smears."
The same percentage said they perform osteoporosis screenings, as well. As key advocates for women's health, ob/gyns evaluate
the bone health of their patients about seven times during a typical week.
Along with Pap testing (fluid-based cytology) and HPV DNA testing, U/S is among the most frequently performed procedures in
an ob/gyn's repertoire. In a typical week, ob/gyns conduct obstetric U/S 18 times and gynecologic U/S 12 times.
Diagnostic tools help provide improved care
 TABLE 2 What is the most frequently used diagnostic test?
|
As you might imagine, hematologic services are the most frequently used diagnostic tool among ob/gyns (Table 2). Respondents
use it an average of 30 times per week. They also order fecal occult blood tests and histology—an average of 23 and 22 times
per week, respectively.
Testing for sexually transmitted diseases—namely, chlamydia and HPV—also ranks high on the list of most frequently ordered
diagnostic tools. Respondents reported that they order tests for chlamydia and HPV an average of 21 and 20 times per week,
respectively.
Substance abuse testing and fetal fibronectin (fFN) screening topped the list of tests that ob/gyns would order in the future.
An increase in testing for drug abuse could ultimately minimize the risk of infant mortality and morbidity. Additionally,
a couple of respondents recognized that screening for fFN helps them improve patient care by decreasing concerns about preterm
labor.
Genetic testing—for purposes other than prenatal use—was cited by four out of 25 respondents as a diagnostic tool they would
order in the future. Nearly seven out of 50 respondents reported that they would order urodynamic testing. Several physicians
noted that urologic testing would not only be beneficial to patients, but would also generate income for their practices.
Where's the money going?
Ob/gyns plan to spend more than $18,000 on new equipment for their practices this year, according to the survey. That's about
three times as much as the amount they projected spending in 2001. While 43% of ob/gyns said their 2005 budget for new equipment
remained the same as in 2004, more than a third reported their current budget has decreased. Less than a quarter saw an increase
in their budget for new devices.
 TABLE 3 What kind of equipment do ob/gyns use?
|
Although respondents said they used computers and software most often in their offices—an average of 30 times and 27 times
per week, respectively—their top purchases this year will be catheters and sutures (Table 3). Next on the shopping list are
cervical samplers—28% said they would make a new or replacement purchase in 2005.
 FIGURE 1 Sources of new medical product and equipment information
|
So where are physicians finding information on new products? Medical journals, reported 75% of respondents (Figure 1). Colleagues
(72%), sales representatives (68%), seminars or conferences (64%), and company literature (63%) are other top sources. Notably,
since 2000, more ob/gyns now rely on CD-ROMs for new product information than the Internet or online databases and video or
audio cassettes.
Once they learn about a new product, ob/gyns aren't quick to pull out their credit cards. Nearly three quarters wait at least
7 months to purchase a new device, and almost half do so 1 or 2 years after it is on the market. In contrast, just 1% of ob/gyns
said they would purchase a new devise as soon as it was available.
The driving motivator for purchasing new equipment was to help meet the current standard of care, reported more than half
of respondents. Almost three out of 10 cited a device's ability to drive revenue as another reason to buy, and nearly a quarter
identified cost as a factor in their purchasing decisions.
Technology's impact: now and beyond
 FIGURE 2 New medical technology that has already had the most impact on ob/gyns practice
|
When asked what device introduced in the last few years had the most impact on their practice, nearly one out of five ob/gyns
cited the new 3D/4D U/S (Figure 2). One male ob/gyn in a group practice in the West noted that he adopted the device, "because
patients were continually asking about it." This demand suggests that acquiring the 3D/4D U/S has the potential to increase
profits, as well. For one male ob/gyn from the East, who sees about 40 patients in a typical week, adopting a 3D/4D U/S was
a positive choice for him and his partner "financially as well as in patient satisfaction."
Almost one out of 10 ob/gyns cited NovaSure ablation as another significant acquisition to their practices in recent years.
Several physicians noted the device's effectiveness in controlling bleeding and avoiding hysterectomy. A male physician in
group practice in the Midwest listed the device's other advantages: "easy to learn, high success (rate), good compensation,
and short duration of procedure."
Next on the list were devices for loop electrosurgical excision procedures (LEEP), cited by 8% of ob/gyns as having already
had an impact on their practices. Several physicians noted that these devices are more "convenient," allowing them to perform
the procedure in the office rather than the hospital.
The top medical device that ob/gyns plan to adopt in the future is a bone densitometer. According to an ob/gyn from the South,
who sees about 150 patients per week, an aging population and an increased awareness about osteoporosis make this piece of
equipment a good future purchase. Already this piece of equipment has made inroads within ob/gyns' practices. According to
one physician from the Midwest, who has already adopted this technology, he saw a "good response from patients and higher
compliance and higher revenue."
 FIGURE 3 New technology ob/gyns think will have the most impact on their future practice
|
Ob/gyns surveyed also believe that in-office endometrial ablation and EMRs will have a future impact on their practices (Figure
3). Patient demand and effectiveness make endometrial ablation a popular acquisition in the near future, while the promise
of fewer medical errors may make EMRs a good buy. Still, at least one ob/gyn—a solo practitioner from the South—noted that
the purchase of EMRs has an upside and a downside: The cost of converting written records into EMRs will have a negative impact
on practices not already using this technology, but ultimately will provide for better management of records.
As technology continues to pervade the practice of medicine, ob/gyns will have to keep up with the latest advancements. These
technological developments not only benefit office-based practices in terms of patient satisfaction and increased revenue,
but also can help improve the quality of obstetric and gynecological care.
REFERENCES
1. U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. "Fact sheet: Harnessing information technology to improve health care." May 6,
2004. http://www.hhs.gov/news/press/2004pres/20040427a.html. Accessed August 31, 2005.